Such proposals are likely to be quite popular. A poll from 2019 found that 58% of voters support canceling all federal student debt. But there are those who question the idea of debt forgiveness and call it unfair to those who never took out student debt or already paid it off. As an ethicist who studies the morality of debt, I see merit in the question: Should student debt be canceled?

The Moral Case Against Canceling

$25,000physicalmentalfamily stability career satisfactioncanceling student debt appearsImmanuel Kant

The Moral Case for Canceling

70% of college students$13,000 to about $30,000$1.5 trillionsecond largestJustin Lewiston and I argue in an articleJohn Rawls defaultrepay only 5%graduation ratesengage20% less than white men10% less than students whose parents graduated20% of student borrowersphysicalmentalfamilieshomesbusinessesdisproportionatelyDeep knowledge, daily.Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter

Avoiding Moral Hazard

Some analystsincreased enrollmentwhile reducing borrowing by over 25%