As usual, there are some upsets, notably with buttered popcorn-flavored jelly beans snagging the number one spot in America. Don’t get too up in arms yet, because it turns out the most popular three flavors aren’t even sweet or fruity, with black licorice and cinnamon taking the second and third spots, respectively. Another notable trend is that buttered popcorn actually unseated black licorice, last year’s winner. As for last place? The honor goes to pomegranate. Check out the map below and see if the rest of your state shares your favorite flavor. Source: 9+ years online candy sales data from CandyStore.com.

This Map Shows the Most Popular Jelly Bean Flavors in Each State - 8